Europe | Charlemagne

The EU’s best-laid plans for expansion are clashing with reality

For now “phoney enlargement” is the order of the day

An EU official with a clipboard standing at the side of a road that goes off into the distance. A large billboard, showing an identical road, with EU stars on the horizon, straddles the road
Illustration: Peter Schrank

After the fall of Poland at the start of the second world war, a paradoxical peace reigned. Carnage was on the cards, but not quite yet. The “phoney war” lasted for eight months, ending when Germany invaded its western neighbours. Today the European Union is going through a “phoney enlargement”. On paper up to nine countries are making progress towards membership. Both in the capitals of the countries looking to join and in Brussels, officials say preparations are being made, reforms enacted, boxes ticked. But whether the mooted expansion will happen is still doubtful. A flush of enthusiasm in the wake of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has given way to the realisation that the journey from 27 to 36 will be long and uncertain. A target of 2030 used to be seen as aspirational. It now looks delusional.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Europe section of the print edition under the headline “Europe’s phoney enlargement”

Is America dictator-proof?

From the May 18th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Europe

Russia’s bloody summer offensive is hurting Ukraine

Kremlin troops are making gains in the Donbas region

How much of a difference will Ukraine’s new F-16s make?

Too few to beat Russia’s air force, but a strong symbolic start


Some Germans think the hostage exchange with Russia was a dirty deal

But preserving good relations with America was more important


The deal that freed Evan Gershkovich was more than a prisoner swap

It freed Russian prisoners of conscience as well as Westerners taken hostage by Vladimir Putin

The Olympics are teaching the French to cheer again

France’s politics is a mess, but the games are glorious

Humiliated by Azerbaijan, Armenia tacks towards the West

Courting the EU and America without alienating Russia is a difficult trick