Europe | Charlemagne

How Europe’s fear of migrants came to dominate its foreign policy

Trade, aid and visas are increasingly conditional on helping Europe stem migration

Two immigrants approach a wall of aid boxes topped with barbed wire
Illustration: Peter Schrank

Asked whether their past imperial behaviour might entitle former colonies to compensation, Europeans like to change the subject by pointing to their generous overseas-development budgets. The continent is home to some of the world’s biggest foreign-aid programmes; a handful of European Union members even meet the aspiration that rich countries should spend 0.7% of their national income on alleviating global poverty. Anyone whose heart has been warmed by reports of schools being built and irrigation systems installed might care to look at the fine print of exactly who is being helped. The Netherlands has in recent years found a new worthy recipient for its supposed generosity: part of the cost of hosting asylum seekers on Dutch soil is now paid from the foreign ministry’s aid budget. Do-gooders howl in protest at the measure, which in effect depletes development spending. Right-wingers say it matters little if an Afghan being helped is in Herat or The Hague, it’s all going to foreigners anyway.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Europe section of the print edition under the headline “The me-first school of diplomacy”

The AI doctor will see you…eventually

From the March 30th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Europe

Russia’s bloody summer offensive is hurting Ukraine

Kremlin troops are making gains in the Donbas region

How much of a difference will Ukraine’s new F-16s make?

Too few to beat Russia’s air force, but a strong symbolic start


Some Germans think the hostage exchange with Russia was a dirty deal

But preserving good relations with America was more important


The deal that freed Evan Gershkovich was more than a prisoner swap

It freed Russian prisoners of conscience as well as Westerners taken hostage by Vladimir Putin

The Olympics are teaching the French to cheer again

France’s politics is a mess, but the games are glorious

Humiliated by Azerbaijan, Armenia tacks towards the West

Courting the EU and America without alienating Russia is a difficult trick