Finance & economics | Too efficient

Are passive funds to blame for market mania?

They have killed off many of those willing to bet on a downturn

The empty Trading Floor of the NYSE after the market has closed.
Photograph: xPACIFICA/Redux/Eyevine

The year is 2034. America’s “magnificent seven” firms make up almost the entirety of the country’s stockmarket. For Jensen Huang, the boss of Nvidia, another knockout quarterly profit means another dizzy proclamation of a “tipping point” in artificial intelligence. Nobody is listening. The long march of passive investing has put the last stockpickers and stock-watchers out of a job. Index mutual and exchange-traded funds (ETFs)—which buy a bunch of stocks rather than guessing which ones will perform best—dominate markets completely. Capitalism’s big questions are hashed out in private between a few tech bosses and asset managers.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Finance & economics section of the print edition under the headline “Too efficient”

India’s north-south divide

From the March 2nd 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Finance & economics

The stockmarket rout may not be over

As investors pause for breath, we assess what could turn a correction into a crash

Why Japanese stocks are on a rollercoaster ride

Volatility in global markets continues


Why Japanese markets have plummeted

The global rout continues, with the Topix experiencing its worst day since 1987


Swing-state economies are doing just fine

They would be doing even better if the Biden-Harris administration had been more cynical

Can Kamala Harris win on the economy?

A visit to a crucial swing state reveals the problems she will face

Why fear is sweeping markets everywhere

American and Japanese indices have taken a battering. So have banks and gold